This is one of those delicate topics. It may be akin to a parent asking a teacher about a problem child. There are so many things to say wrong that may be taking out of context.
Let me try to politely sum it up this way.
1. The oxidation was avoidable, and should NOT have happened in either of the cases.
2. It is fixable without having to paint. Oxidation can be restored if you move quickly.
3. It takes some work to keep it up, either by a diligent owner, or a qualified professional.
Let me give a little context from my perspective. Before buying my RV what both of you state was one of my primary concerns. Back then (before Covid), you could see brand new RVs on a lot with the oxidation issues. I passed on several as they were just too bad for me. Some even had cracking decals. I couldn't believe it
I bought my RV brand new in 2019. I was motivated to the point I may have overdone my waxing and detailing a tad; but my goal was to ensure my investment would NEVER be like what you guys describe
Here is what I do.
I wax my RV twice a year (5 hrs labor each time) with $20 of wax Meguiars #83 and/or #56. I wax the roof with #83 ( actually it is a Cleaner Polish / Glaze). I treat the decals & rubber on window seals every 2 months with 303 Aerospace Protectant (10 min). I wash the RV after every trip with Gel Gloss RV Wash & Wax ( 1 hr)
I first waxed my RV the 1st week I brought it home back in Nov 2019. I have waxed it 4 times since then; the most recent was 2 weeks ago.
See pictures.
I should add, my RV is stored at my home in the Texas heat and sun 24/7, it is also parked under a Cedar tree that sheds leaves twice a year. No inside storage, No cover, No shed, No $25k full body paint, just kept outside... and I don't worry which side is facing the sun, because my RV is always protected.
Point of all of this...
This is what is possible from a Winnebago RV 3 1/2 years old. Everyone may not be able to do what I have done, but something in between will get you results that is also something in between. Make no mistake there is strong correlation with how effective you have maintained the Fiberglass on your RV with amount of Oxidation you may see.
What to do...
Find someone that is proven to know how to remove the oxidation to restore the finish. They will need a buffer/polisher.
Please do not try to learn to use a buffer on your RV. Once the Oxidation is removed, have it polished with some one who knows what they are doing. At this point, most RV owners can wax and maintain it themselves following steps I laid out above. It does no good to wax a poorly prepped surface.
Note: I have never had to remove oxidation like you guys are referencing. My methods are more on
prevention, not correction. Every time I see or read of finish issues on RVs, I get more motivation to want to do my next wax which is not due until November.
I hope this helps, and if there are specific questions just let me know.
Koldman