Quote:
Originally Posted by NeilV
Yes and No on the better. In the storage lot and tight spaces the side opening doors can be a detriment as they are usually so long that they can only be opened a fraction of the way making it so you can only easily access one end of the bin plus they are more prone to damage due to the hinges being on the short end of the doors. Side opening doors also provide little to no rain protection making it so the bins get wetter when its raining out and you open them.
I tried a few coaches with them and overall did not like the side opening doors which also can block you when opening multiple bins.
|
You pointed out an excellent trade-off on the top hinge opening versus side swing hinge opening. When we were performing the pre-delivery checklist on our coach, the PDI tech was also the dealers service guy, he opened each of the exterior storage bins for us as we walked around. He stated that this was the best exterior storage door design. I asked why and he pointed to their service bay where he stated they had one Newmar and two Tiffin coaches in there getting storage bin door repairs. He stated inevitably owners tend to place their body weight on the side opening door. Whether leaning in to look for something or used as a "grab rail" to pull themselves up off the ground, the door/hinge is not designed to handle that weight and rips out.
I mentioned that it would be helpful if Winnebago allowed more than 90 degree opening range. The serivce guy replied that opening angle was done on purpose by Winnebago. He said at 90 degree, the storage door would not direct rain water into the storage bin. When he release the restraint cable and you can easily see that at that angle, the storage door would certainly direct water into the storage area. He said a number of owners say they don't leave their storage doors open but he said he has seen his share of swamped storage bins.
We were thankful for having a knowlegable PDI tech. He was very enlightening on a number items.
Point is, we often look at things with RV design "now why did they do that?"; with Winnebago it is usually because it was a problem that surfaced years ago from owner input so they upgraded. I now appreciate the trade-off of the lower crawling.
Bobby